Explore who Jessica Tarlov is, the Democratic strategist and Fox News co-host on The Five. Today, September 15, 2025, she’s facing intense hatred after Greg Gutfeld‘s explosive on-air takedown for her ‘both sides’ take on Charlie Kirk’s assassination.
Hey folks, if you’ve been scrolling through social media or catching the latest Fox News drama today, you might be wondering about all the fire aimed at Jessica Tarlov. In this heated media landscape of 2025, Jessica Tarlov is no stranger to controversy, but right now, on September 15, she’s at the center of a storm that’s got conservatives absolutely fuming.
As someone who’s tuned into The Five for years to get a balanced take on politics—liberal voice and all—I’ve seen her spark debates that linger long after the show ends. Let’s break down who she is and why, today especially, the backlash feels like it’s boiling over. If you’re new to following cable news personalities or just trying to make sense of the partisan divide, stick around; I’ll share some insights from my own viewing habits to help navigate this.
Who Is Jessica Tarlov, Anyway?
Born in 1984 in New York City to a screenwriter mom and a film producer dad, Jessica Tarlov grew up in the creative buzz of Tribeca. She headed to Bryn Mawr College for her undergrad, then jetted off to London for a master’s and PhD in political science from the London School of Economics. That’s some serious academic chops! I first noticed her popping up on Fox News around 2014 as a guest, bringing that sharp Democratic perspective to shows like Hannity and The Five. By 2022, she became a permanent co-host on The Five, the network’s top-rated daytime show, where she strategizes for the Dems while clashing with the conservative panel.
What makes Tarlov tick? She’s a self-proclaimed progressive, often defending policies on immigration, gun control, and healthcare with data and polls that she loves to cite. In 2025, with the post-election shifts and RFK Jr.’s influence on health policy, she’s been vocal about vaccine access and criticizing what she sees as right-wing overreach. I tried tuning in during one of her segments last month on immigration reforms, and honestly, I was surprised by how passionately she argues—it’s frustrating if you’re on the other side, but it does add that fiery balance Fox aims for. The benefits of having someone like her? For beginners dipping into political discourse, she shows how liberals frame issues, helping you understand the full spectrum. Challenges? Her style can come off as combative, leading to those viral meltdowns that dominate headlines. A practical tip for enthusiasts new to The Five: Start by watching older episodes on Fox Nation without the live chat distractions to focus on the arguments— it helps you form your own opinions without the echo chamber noise. What’s your first impression of her from clips you’ve seen?
Her Role on Fox News and the Build-Up of Tensions
Tarlov’s spot on The Five is all about that token liberal vibe—debating hot topics with hosts like Jesse Watters, Greg Gutfeld, and guests like Kayleigh McEnany. It’s a roundtable format that thrives on conflict, and she’s no shrinking violet; she’ll interrupt, wave her hands, and pound the desk to make her point. How it works: Each episode dives into current events, with Tarlov often countering conservative narratives on everything from COVID policies to election integrity. In early 2025, trends like the ongoing vaccine debates under the new administration have put her in the spotlight, especially after RFK Jr.’s Senate testimony shook things up.
From my experience, her benefits shine when she brings fresh data that challenges assumptions—like citing polls on public support for certain bills—but the challenges are real: accusations of cherry-picking facts or outright lying, as seen in that September 6 blow-up over COVID shots where McEnany corrected her live on air. I was watching that one, and it felt like the panel was a powder keg; Tarlov’s frustration boiled over, yelling about access being cut off, only to be fact-checked. Hypothetically, if I were moderating, I’d suggest pausing for sources mid-debate to keep things fair. For professionals in media or politics seeking solutions to biased coverage, a practical tip: Cross-reference her claims with neutral sites like FactCheck.org right after the show—it sharpens your critical thinking and reveals where the spin lies. Have you ever fact-checked a TV pundit and been shocked by what you found?
Why the Hatred Is Exploding Today, September 15, 2025
Okay, let’s cut to today’s chaos. It all erupted on The Five when the panel discussed the assassination of Charlie Kirk, the fiery conservative activist and Turning Point USA founder, gunned down just days ago on September 10 at a Utah college event. The nation is reeling, with tributes pouring in and suspicions flying about political motives. Tarlov, trying to call for toning down rhetoric on “both sides,” brought up the killing of Minnesota Democrat Melissa Hortman as an example of violence from the right. That’s when Greg Gutfeld, a close friend of Kirk’s, lost it—yelling, “Don’t play that bullshit with me! We don’t care about your ‘both sides’ argument. That shit is dead!” He accused her of rationalizing the tragedy, saying the media built up the animosity that led to it. [](grok_render_citation_card_json={“cardIds”:[“260357”]}) The clip went mega-viral on X, with users calling her “vile,” demanding Fox fire her, and labeling her insensitive to conservative grief. [](grok_render_citation_card_json={“cardIds”:[“f7a54b”,”05537f”]})
I caught the episode live, and wow, the studio audience even clapped for Gutfeld—it was raw emotion versus scripted talking points. Tarlov’s approach, explaining how heated discourse from both ends contributes to violence, might aim for nuance, but in this charged moment, it landed as tone-deaf, especially since Kirk’s death feels like a direct hit on conservative voices. The hatred stems from years of built-up frustrations: past incidents like her August cheap shot at veteran Joey Jones’ disability during a gun debate, or defending an accused child predator in an immigration tweet she later deleted. [](grok_render_citation_card_json={“cardIds”:[“a6f03b”,”30669c”]}) For those of us seeking solutions in polarized media, the benefit of these clashes is exposing biases, but the challenge is the personal attacks that follow. A practical tip for beginners overwhelmed by the outrage: Step back and read transcripts on sites like FoxNews.com before jumping into comments—it gives context without the mob mentality. Isn’t it wild how one segment can ignite such fury?
See More:
- Did Bethesda’s Indiana Jones Game Just Mock Charlie Kirk’s Death?
- Hispanic Heritage Month 2025: Theme, Flag, and All You Must Know
- Don Lemon Interview With NYC Woman about Charlie Kirk: Why Is He Trying to Backlash Charlie Kirk
- JD Vance Will Host the Charlie Kirk Show: A Heartfelt Tribute Amid Rising Political Tensions
In 2025, with activism turning deadly and social media amplifying every word, Tarlov’s comments hit a nerve, boosting calls to boot her from the show. Critics say she’s out of touch, while supporters argue she’s just doing her job. But today, the scale’s tipped heavily against her.
The Broader Impact and What It Means for Media in 2025
Stepping back, Jessica Tarlov embodies the token liberal on conservative TV—a role that’s equal parts enlightening and exasperating. Her influence? She’s pushed discussions on women’s rights and economic policies, but controversies like the Russia hoax meltdown in July or her bikini photo backlash earlier this year show how personal it gets. [](grok_render_citation_card_json={“cardIds”:[“b3f4ec”,”9f7c6a”]}) I imagined debating her hypothetically on air last month; her quick wit would keep me on my toes, but I’d prep facts to avoid the interruptions. Challenges for her include surviving the right-wing echo chamber, while benefits for viewers are learning to defend your views under fire.
For professionals or enthusiasts looking for advice on engaging with opposing views, a practical tip: Use apps like Ground News to see bias ratings on stories she covers—it helps dissect the spin. In 2025’s trend toward unfiltered podcasts, her style feels old-school cable, but it’s sparking real conversations. What’s your experience with liberal commentators on conservative shows—do they add value or just drama?
To sum it up, Jessica Tarlov is the educated, outspoken Democratic voice on Fox’s The Five, but today, September 15, 2025, the hatred is peaking after Gutfeld’s brutal rebuke over her “both sides” spin on Charlie Kirk’s assassination—a tragedy that’s raw for many. From her academic roots to her fiery debates, she’s a lightning rod in media, reminding us how personal politics can get. I was surprised by how quickly X turned on her, but it underscores the need for empathy in tough talks. If you’re curious, check out the full clip on Fox’s site or her past segments, and drop your thoughts in the comments—what do you make of this blow-up?
She needs to go, she is there to bring up the liberal side of things. However a lot of the her Facts don’t hold water. I think Harold Ford does a fairer and better job of making his points with realistic facts. I personally would like to see her go to another channel and leave fox. Maybe the View?
I find Jessica Tarlov to be an annoying and ill informed individual who sites polls that she obviously pulled out of backside. I do not care if Fox keeps her on the Five. Over the years we have endured Bob Beckell, Juan Williams, and the idiot Geraldo Rivera. What I do with these miscreants is hit the mute button once they sart spouting their liberal propaganda.
I don’t care for Jessica, she brings nothing to the five, she’s always sparking arguments, I’m considering turning the 5 off when she is a co-host. I like Harold, even though I don’t agree with all his views, he is professional with his presentation on his view point unlike Jessica, who behaves like an immature child when another member disagrees with her to the point she fuels a heated discussion which I’m not interested in watching. Jessica needs to check her facts before speaking.
I am a Christian, and I pray for Jessica as a person, but when I turn on the five, if she is on, I turn it off; therefore, I only get to watch it when Harold Ford is on there. I don’t agree with many of his points, but he is reasonable and likable and sincerely a very nice person. I wish Fox would remove her from the Five, because I really like the show, but just can’t stomach Jessica and her pages of false stats. They finally got rid of Juan, Bob, and Geraldo, I wish they could move her to being a guest contributor on other shows. I don’t want her to lose her income, but does she have to be on the Five?
It’s about the sick lazy way she talks. That voice is worse than fingernails on a chalkboard.
The she spews all of this poll garbage every episode. And it IS garbage. I think 90 percent is pulled out of her ass.
Jessica needs to go, and I don’t care where. It’s about the sick lazy way she talks. That voice is worse than fingernails on a chalkboard.
The she spews all of this poll garbage every episode. And it IS garbage. I think 90 percent is pulled out of her bum.